FISHING BENEATH A
by Randy Kadish
nurse said, "You failed the vision test."
"Failed? I thought wearing
contact lenses were okay?"
"To be a court officer you
have to meet certain requirements, without glasses or contacts."
"But I did so well on the
"Our rules are firm."
Sarcastically, I said, "Written in
stone, I guess."
The white ceiling, the yellow
walls, and my hopes seemed to be closing in on me. I jumped up and
left the office.
Outside, I thought, I was so
sure I had the job, the way, years ago, I was so sure I’d be a
famous writer by the time I was twenty-five. Sometimes I feel like
I’m cursed, as if my failing the eye test a reflection of me.
During the rest of the long, long
day and the next morning, I felt as if I was being pulled into a rip
tide of grief. I was afraid of drowning. Don’t panic. Swim out of
it. How? Believe in a loving Higher Power? If it were only so easy.
But I suppose everything I learned in recovery is sort of a Higher
Power. Yes, I can stay in the moment. I can remind myself I didn’t
cause the state’s requirements. And I can go fishing. That’s how I
swam out of my grief over my mother’s death.
I took my fly-fishing equipment,
rode the Path train to Hoboken, and walked to the long, wide,
concrete pier. Covering most of the pier was a big lawn. The pier,
therefore, was clearly designed to look like a small park. Parallel
to the park or pier, about two hundred feet down river, was the old,
Lackawana, ferry terminal. The side of the terminal was getting a
facelift, but not for the better, in my opinion. The new face was
flat and white, emptied of the flowing, baroque-like ornamentation
of the old green facade.
I looked up. The thick, gray clouds
seemed to form a high ceiling, reminding me of the inside of a huge,
marble building. Though the blue sky was closed off, the forecast
didn’t predict rain; so the clouds weren’t ominous, especially
because they were somewhere between gray and white.
The Hudson River was murky, and
didn’t reflect sunlight, failure, disappointment or anything else.
The Hudson River was calm, as if most of it, except its thin,
flowing surface, was an immovable highway. The river was murky and I
wondered if the river not reflecting sunlight or anything else was
some sort of metaphor of my life I tried to come up with one. I took
out my small pad, but the page remained blank. Maybe I’m really
at a dead end as a writer. I reminded myself I was losing
precious fishing time. I put the pad away.
Because of the cloud ceiling, I
guessed the stripers, if they were around, would be close to the
surface. I decided to fish a popper on a floating, shooting-head
line. I put my fly rod together and screwed on the reel. Suddenly,
cracks appeared in the clouds. Streaks of sunlight poured through,
decorating the water like rhinestones on a shirt.
I hope the cracks in the clouds
don’t get bigger, let in more sun and send the stripers deeper.
Maybe the clouds will expand and plaster up the cracks.
I wished the answers to catching
fish were as rigid as the state’s vision requirements, and then
placed my bet on the sun coming out: I put on my fast-sinking line,
and tied on a white deceiver. I walked onto the lawn, pulled more
than a hundred feet of line off the reel, and stretched the coils,
about three feet at a time, out of my line.
How strange, that after so many
years of practicing and trying to discover long-distance,
fly-casting techniques, I only recently saw that even loose coils in
the line caused friction and weakened my casts. To compensate, I
usually cast too hard, and caused my casting loops to tail. Yes,
when it comes to fly casting, I’m always learning.
I put on my stripping basket,
retrieved the line and walked to the end of the pier. The skyline of
lower Manhattan came into view. Sunlight tinted the sides of some of
the buildings. I thought of a Vermeer painting, of sunlight shinning
through a small window and falling on a woman’s face. I wondered,
though I knew it wasn’t true, if nature had learned from Vermeer.
The Manhattan skyline looked more
awesome than I remembered. Is it because for the first time in
over a year I’m seeing it from New Jersey, from a western
perspective? Though many of the buildings were from different
eras, and though each building was from a different design, they all
seemed to match, like mountains in a range. Maybe the buildings
match because of luck. And the Catskill Mountains? They match
because of nature. And how long does nature take to form a mountain
range? Are ranges, like the Manhattan skyline, works in progress?
Are ranges formed because nature, like humanity, spent thousands of
years discovering, one by one, the techniques of engineering and
construction? Maybe even nature is learning.
In my mind I tried to fast forward
a hundred years and see how the skyline looked. I couldn’t, even
though I was wearing contacts lenses.
I reached into my pocket and took
out my long-distance, fly-casting notes. I studied the techniques
and visualized them. I false cast, shooting more and more line.
Finally the whole shooting head and twelve feet of running line were
outside of the rod tip. I cast back, reminding myself to keep my
elbow in. I hauled downward, then waited for a second. Keeping my
shoulders still, I looked back. My loop was tight. I shot line and
slowly pointed the rod lower, to about two o’clock. I hauled upward.
When my line hand reached my rod hand, I cast forward, then hauled
straight downward. I moved both hands faster and faster. I shifted
my weight all the way forward and extended my casting arm. Abruptly
I stopped the rod. I let go of the line and raised the rod butt.
The line arrowed downstream. The
front loop unrolled. My deceiver turned over perfectly and dived in
the water. Proud, I looked for the fifty-foot mark I had put on my
line. The mark was just inside the rod tip. I had cast about 105
No, I wasn’t cursed. Maybe the
murky, non-reflective water is just what it is, and not a symbol or
metaphor of anything, and neither is my failing the eye exam.
I retrieved as fast as I could and
rewound my mind back to when I was forty-six and was sure I landed a
new job. But Fedex didn’t call. Disappointed, wanting to erase
another failure, I finished my third fishing article. A few days
later, an editor offered to publish it. Grateful, I told myself that
in spite of my failure to write the great American novel, I might as
well try to write and sell fishing articles. Maybe then people, as
well as myself, wouldn’t see me as a failed writer.
And so I wrote and wrote, and after
eight years of writing, of revising, I grew tired, especially
because I didn’t see anything new to say. I wanted a career change,
a steady income, and, I hoped, a son or a daughter I could teach the
fly-casting techniques I had struggled to learned. But as I stood on
the Hoboken Pier, I no longer saw fatherhood or much of a future
ahead of me.
Again I cast about 100 feet. I
retrieved, a little slower this time, and remembered how I never
thought writing articles for local, outdoor magazines would lead to
my writing memoirs and a fly fishing novel, both reflecting my
emotional recovery. Yes, the memoirs and book unfolded in my
mind, little by little, by themselves, it seems. Could it be that
Fedex did not offer me a job right away for a reason? Did some
unseen architect design the grand scheme of my life so I became a
writer? But the idea is opposite of everything I believe: that the
world is often random and violent, a tale, as Shakespeare says, told
by an idiot.
Again I false cast. I began my
forward, presentation cast. I accelerated then abruptly stopped the
rod and let go of the line. The fly rod seemed to come apart. Did
I lose the top half of my $600 rod? Another massive disappointment.
The world always hits me when I’m down. Damn it!
The rod was there, all of it. I was
grateful. The running line was in my stripping basket. I realized
the small loop connecting the shooting head to the running line
broke. Now I’ll have to spend another thirty bucks for a new
I put on my floating line, tied on
a popper, and cast across stream, toward Manhattan. I retrieved,
repeatedly jerking the rod tip to the side, banging the popper
though the surface so that it splashed and sprayed water like a
miniature speed boat. I reminded myself not to look at the popper,
so if I got a strike I wouldn’t pull the popper out of the striper’s
Down river, the Hudson flowed into
the harbor. It seemed amazing that a shallow, tree-lined stream in
upstate New York could turn into a deep, building-lined river. Was
the Hudson, therefore, a reflection of the flow of humanity? After
all, our knowledge supposedly deepened as generations flowed on. But
the Hudson eventually flowed into the ocean and lost its shape and
identity. Perhaps if it knew where it was flowing it would turn
around and go back. But whether I want to or not, I know where
I’m flowing: toward the final unknown, toward losing my shape and
identity, unless some of my writing keeps me alive, like the
children I don’t have, in the annals of fly fishing. And before I
reach the final unknown, what will my future be like? A dead end? If
only I could turn around and become a doctor instead of a writer, a
forgiving son instead of an angry one. But like the banks of the
Hudson, my past is shaped in stone.
Something, I saw, was wrapped
around the bottom of the railing—my shooting head! A miracle, it
seemed. Grateful, I pulled the line up, wrapped it around my hand,
and put it into my vest pocket. Thirty bucks—the cost of twenty
Again I cast, this time about 108
feet! I retrieved. Yes, I’m a spoiled angler, lucky to have days
off during the week so I can fish any river, lake or pier, without
worrying about crowds.
A strike! I whipped my fly rod up
and pulled down on the line. The striper pulled back hard. He was
on. I let him run. He bolted upriver. I didn’t try to slow or turn
him. He circled, as if he didn’t know where to go. Finally, he
tired. Slowly, I reeled him close to the pier. I pointed the rod
straight up, toward the sky, and grabbed the line. Hand over hand, I
pulled the striper up. He was about thirty inches, a keeper, if I
wanted to take life. I took the hook out of the striper’s mouth and
dropped him back into the river.
I fished for about another hour,
and though I didn’t get another strike, I felt that, on this day in
this small world of the Hoboken Pier, I won and the fish lost.
I took apart the fly rod and
screwed off the reel. Breaking a loop connector and having to
change lines: could it too have been meant to be? Certainly when it
came to deciding what level to fish, I didn’t have the answer, the
way for so long I didn’t have the answers to fly casting or, like a
circling striper, to the direction I should go. After all, without
my difficult childhood and my failures, events I couldn’t
understand, I wouldn’t have journeyed down the road I wrote about:
spiritual recovery. Yes, my painful past was meant to be. And
perhaps the high tide of my recent disappointment will slacken and
carry me to a new turn in the road of life. Yes, in a way the state
was right: When it comes to seeing, at least into the future, my
vision is blurred, for better or worse.
I sat on a bench, lit a cigar, and
watched the sun set. The smoke rose and blended into the
marble-looking ceiling of gray clouds. The ceiling grew dark—it
seemed eerie—but as the lights of New York grew brighter, as the
city, like a night owl with a million eyes, came alive, it seemed to
me as if it were sculpted from the marble sky.
Wow! What a great day to be
Text and photos by Randy Kadish 2008 ©
Randy's historical novel,
The Fly Caster Who Tried To Make
Peace With The World, is available on